Во первых, если уж читаете перед обедом советские газеты, проверяйте полученную там информацию в первоисточниках, прежде чем использовать ее для аргументации:
"The pictures in 2004 and 2006 were taken using a high-resolution channel on the Hubble's Advanced Camera for Surveys that failed in 2007 and was not restored when the camera was brought back online in 2009. For the latest image, Kalas had to resort to another Hubble instrument, the Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph. He says the switch to a different detector may explain the planet's slight deviation from its expected position. He has been allocated time to take another picture with that same instrument next summer. If the planet's unexpected motion persists, he says it is still possible to explain why the disk around the star is undisturbed: perhaps his team is seeing the planet just as some dynamic instability in the star system is knocking it off course. ... Jean Schneider, an astronomer at the Paris Observatory who maintains the exoplanet.eu database, says that Fomalhaut b will remain on the list. But on 22 September, he added a comment to the planet's entry saying that doubts have been raised."
А во вторых, если даже так, то что? Экзопланет известно тысячи, газовопылевых дисков тоже завались, но вот обещанных Лариным эффектов, "...зона стала светить жемчужно белым светом. ... кольца ... засияли как яркая реклама в сумерках", никто пока что не видел.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
timeasmymeasure
Re: экзопланеты не экзопланеты
Date: 2011-09-24 06:27 pm (UTC)http://www.nature.com/news/2011/110923/full/news.2011.555.html
"The pictures in 2004 and 2006 were taken using a high-resolution channel on the Hubble's Advanced Camera for Surveys that failed in 2007 and was not restored when the camera was brought back online in 2009. For the latest image, Kalas had to resort to another Hubble instrument, the Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph. He says the switch to a different detector may explain the planet's slight deviation from its expected position. He has been allocated time to take another picture with that same instrument next summer. If the planet's unexpected motion persists, he says it is still possible to explain why the disk around the star is undisturbed: perhaps his team is seeing the planet just as some dynamic instability in the star system is knocking it off course.
...
Jean Schneider, an astronomer at the Paris Observatory who maintains the exoplanet.eu database, says that Fomalhaut b will remain on the list. But on 22 September, he added a comment to the planet's entry saying that doubts have been raised."
А во вторых, если даже так, то что? Экзопланет известно тысячи, газовопылевых дисков тоже завались, но вот обещанных Лариным эффектов, "...зона стала светить жемчужно белым светом. ... кольца ... засияли как яркая реклама в сумерках", никто пока что не видел.